OVERALL GRADE
D Limited
Photo unavailable
PLAYER PROFILE
Payton Tolle
Starting Pitcher • Boston Red Sox
Bats:
Left
Throws:
Left
Age:
23
Height:
6' 6"
Weight:
250 lbs
UNDERSTAND THE PLAYER
Player IQ
IQ SCORE
63 Out of 100CURRENT ROLE
Starting Pitcher
This role reflects official MLB position information and available current-season usage. It is not a projection.
30-SECOND IQ
The quick read on Payton Tolle
Payton Tolle currently profiles as a limited pitching performer. W is the strongest verified indicator, while BB/9 represents the clearest relative development opportunity.
WHY THIS SCORE
- ERA: 68th percentile (Would rank #19)
- WHIP: 62th percentile (Would rank #22)
- K/9: 66th percentile (Would rank #20)
- BB/9: 54th percentile (Would rank #27)
2026 PITCHING
Pitching Statistics
ERA
3.30
Would rank #19
Top 32% vs qualifiers
Earned runs allowed per nine innings.
WHIP
1.15
Would rank #22
Top 38% vs qualifiers
Walks plus hits allowed per inning pitched.
W–L
6–6
W
#64 MLB
Top 8%
IP
101.0
#85 MLB
Top 11%
Innings pitched.
SO
110
#42 MLB
Top 5%
BB
29
SV
0
#216 MLB
Top 28%
G
18
VERIFIED CAREER CONTEXT
Player Career Hub
Loading verified career and award records…
UNDERSTAND THE PLAYER
Scout Report
ARCHETYPE
Starting Pitcher
Available current-season rate statistics are compared directionally with the qualified MLB pitcher pool. These are not official rankings.
DATA CONFIDENCE
Moderate confidence
Compared with qualified MLB pitchers, but this is not an official qualified ranking.
STRENGTHS
Verified indicators
Percentile-based strengths are withheld until the player officially qualifies.
NEEDS IMPROVEMENT
Areas to monitor
-
Home-Run Suppression Directional comparison
Why: Directional comparison (101.0 IP across 18 appearances, including 18 starts): 1.07 HR/9 would place #33 against 57 qualified MLB pitchers (43rd percentile). This is not an official rank. It is the lowest supported league-relative category in this report, not a below-average classification.
VERSATILITY
No verified season position usage
- Primary role or position
- Starting Pitcher
- Position / role entries
- 0
- Verified secondary positions
- None in available season position data
This report summarizes available 2026 MLB statistics and official position information and available season usage. Non-qualified comparisons are directional, not official leaderboard ranks. Percentiles are calculated by IQDugout from official MLB comparison pools. Confidence reflects sample size, qualification, and supported comparison coverage. Versatility labels summarize verified position usage and are not league benchmarks. This is a current-data evaluation, not a projection.